Stronger Leaders Make Stronger Employees
By Christine Perkins
An employee presents a recommendation at a team meeting. One of the executives pushes back. “What makes you think this will work?”
The employee pauses. Their manager jumps in, explains the reasoning, and answers the follow-up question. The manager thinks they’ve saved their employee from an uncomfortable moment. But the employee leaves the meeting without having had the chance to explain a recommendation they worked hard to develop. And the next time an executive challenges their thinking, they’ll still be figuring out how to respond.
The leader’s job starts before the meeting
If you’ve been in that room before, you know things your employee may have no way of knowing. You know which questions tend to come up, what the executives care about, and where they’re likely to challenge a recommendation. Share what you know while there’s still time to use it.
Sit down with the employee before the meeting. Ask the questions you expect the executives to ask. “What would this cost?” “What would we have to put aside to do it?” “What would make you change your recommendation?” Then let the employee answer in their own words. If they struggle, talk through what’s missing and let them try again.
Also talk about what to do when a question comes up that neither of you saw coming. Sometimes the strongest answer is, “I’d like to check that and come back to you.” Give them room to say that.
Let them do the work you prepared them to do
Once you’re in the meeting, give them the floor. When someone pushes back, give them a moment to think. If they stumble through an answer, let them finish. The answer might be imperfect. Their recommendation might even get turned down. They can learn from both.
Hearing you give a good answer can help. Having to find their own answer while someone is challenging their thinking teaches them something they can use the next time they’re in that room.
Afterward, ask what they heard in the executive’s question and what they’d say if they had another shot at it. Share what you noticed. If the recommendation was turned down, help them figure out what they’d change and give them a chance to bring it back. That’s how you build trust through a hard conversation. They know you’ll prepare them, give them room to handle it, and help them learn from how it went.
What to do now
1. Before the next executive meeting, rehearse the hardest question.
Ask your employee which question they’re most worried about. Share the one you think is most likely to come up. Practice both, then agree on when they want you to step in. In the meeting, give them time to answer. Afterward, ask which question they’d handle differently and have them try that answer with you.
2. In a warehouse, let a shift lead run the response to a backlog.
Before a busy shift, walk through what the lead can do if orders start piling up at packing. Ask how they’d spot the problem, which trained people they could move, and when they’d call you. When the backlog happens, give them room to make the call you prepared them to make. After the shift, look at what happened together. If the first move didn’t clear the backlog, ask what they’d try sooner next time.
Before you step in, ask yourself what your employee needs from you right now. Sometimes they need an answer. Sometimes they need a few more seconds to give their own.
If your managers tend to step in when conversations get tough, give them a chance to practice coaching their teams through those moments. Explore leadership development workshops to help managers prepare employees, give them room to respond, and offer feedback afterward.